The Ancient City
by Numa Denis Fustel de Coulanges

Fustel de Coulanges’s The Ancient City is like a factory reset for how we moderns think about ancient cultures. When we read books on Ancient Greece or Rome, it’s easy to drop ourselves into those situations, interpreting events of the time through our own lens of values. Coulanges emphasizes how misleading that is. Ancient religious beliefs, kinship structures, and ideas on moral obligations were so different from ours that even familiar stories look strange. If you've ever read the Iliad or The Aeneid or any works of mythology, you've probably noticed some big differences in what was considered respectable or heroic. Hyperviolence, cruelty, slavery were all accepted realities. Their ideas of heroism could accommodate a level of violence and domination that’s hard to square with ours. Coulanges helps us trace the lineage of cultural change to see where these belief systems and social norms came from.

One of the parts I found most interesting is how far back Coulanges goes, before the Greece and Rome we usually read about, to clan/tribe precursor societies, when religion was something personal to each family. Each household had its own gods, its own ancestors to honor, its own rituals centered around the hearth. Religion, law, politics, and kinship were all commingled into this single household structure — it was all bundled together. The same beliefs that governed worship also governed marriage, inheritance, authority, morality. Coulanges then follows how those households came together into larger groups and eventually cities, carrying that whole structure of beliefs and rituals along with them. You start to see how much history sits beneath Greek and Roman polytheistic societies, with their many gods presiding over different aspects of life. Once upon a time these gods were personal to smaller groups. The likes of Apollo, Demeter, Hestia, or Hermes arose from precursor gods of families, then tribes, then cities. When we meet the pantheon in the Athens of popular history books, it's been cobbled together over centuries from separate and distinct religions.
It's interesting how traditions and cultural norms morph along the way: which rituals disappear, which take new forms, and which survive even after people forget where they came from. Customs sometimes continue to serve a purpose even when the people practicing them can no longer explain it. We inherit ways of doing things because they work, often without understanding what makes them work.
The book closes on the birth of Christianity, another radical transformation of the beliefs that held these societies together. You notice how much of the moral distance between us and the ancient world comes from that inheritance. In the West, we’re so accustomed to Christian-inflected values that putting ourselves in the ancients’ shoes takes a pretty radical rethink of our worldview.
Coulanges goes deep enough into each subject to make it interesting without belaboring each topic. For something written by a 19th century French academic, I expected great information, but a certain amount of dryness. But it was a pleasantly engaging read.

























